Originally Posted by
Pierless
As far as the party boat, a group of 8 with 5 of them under 12 is going to struggle. The smaller kids won't be tall enough to work a rod over the side of the boat, and I doubt a 12 year old will be able to successfully fish without assistance unless he/she is already practiced at working a conventional reel. December seas tend to be higher than summer seas as well, and the party boat isn't going to cancel for 3 footers should they have enough people to run (which is a toss up anyway). Target species will be small reef dwellers like beeliners and porgies. Snappers and triggers are closed.
Sometimes this is far from the case, regardless of captain and crew experience. It can also be a fishless vomit and tangle fest.