Leaving Fish On the Deck (continued)
It's such an interesting discussion, with so many different facets -- I thought it'd be a good idea to continue it here, rather than in "dated fishing reports".
Regarding leaving fish out on the deck, even though I'm a responsible person who would always care for my catch, I have to be aware of the optics - how things look to others." Do neophyte fishermen see me leaving fish out and think that this is what you do with fish you don't want to take home?"
I think that the responsible, proper thing to do is to know what you want to do with a fish before you hook it. If you're king fishing and you're NOT planning on keeping it, then you can, 1) pre-arrange with another fisherman to let him have your fish if you catch one 2) make that offer after you hook up, but before the fish is gaffed 3) break the fish off if there are no takers. It might be a good idea to ask the person who wants the king if he has a cooler to put it in. You can also 4) net the fish and retrieve your plug/hook, then let the fish swim free by putting him back in the net and releasing it.
You can do this, whether the fish is a king, redfish, or big black drum. I think that it's never appropriate, ever, to just throw baitfish or "trash fish" on the deck of the pier. Whether it's hardhead catfish, rays, or remoras, these fish play an important role in the ecosystem, mostly keeping the Gulf waters clean.
I think that the pier needs to post the rule that fish are to be immediately put in coolers. That puts the onus on fishermen to figure out how to comply with a rule that would result in a fine if they don't comply. Personally, I'm not going to tell another fisherman what MY preferences are for him to do with HIS catch, unless he's breaking the rules. If the rule is that he HAS to put his fish in his cooler or throw it back (or give it to another fishermen) the problem is solved. The pier bait shop may sell more coolers as a result.
ChileRelleno brought up an interesting point about the lack of cleanliness of the cleaning station. I totally agree and I don't know the answer to this, short of pier personnel somehow regularly disinfecting the station (pretty sure they don't do this) and even then, maybe I should bring a cutting board to put my fish on when I clean them (I have one suitable for that purpose). I'm open to ideas since bringing fish carcasses home isn't a very good option for me.