Sheepshead story:
Years ago (like 20) I fished the rigs just south of Dauphin Island with a guy and his son in their boat.
Jemisons had no live shrimp tha day and we had to settle for the week old 'bait shrimp'.
You know, the stuff that the heads are falling off of :rolleyes:
Anyway, we got 0 bites until I made a drop rig and threaded the shrimp up onto the hook (so as to resemble a ghost shrimp).
http://pad1.whstatic.com/images/thum...imp-Step-6.jpg
We literally filled the box over the next few hours until we ran out of shrimp.
I don't believe they would have bit LIVE shrimp any better that day.
Of course that was late March though.
Small croakers, ground mullet, silver perch, white trout, grunts, pinfish etc. can just as 'picky' some times.
If my bait is being 'pecked' off (and that is the ONLY bites I am getting), I will either move to another spot or rig up using smaller hooks on a lighter lighter rig and line to see what the 'tiddlers' are.
Carazy thing, several times when I've done just that I ended up hooking (and usually catching) some MUCH larger fish in amongst the peewees ;-)